Plan 9 from Outer Space: Ed Wood’s famously-bad movie starring Bela Lugosi, who died after shooting only five minutes of film: 62%. Granted, this is skewed by the camp value of the result. ... The Dukes of Hazzard: Car chases and short shorts. Not exactly Oscar material. 14% ... Left Behind: Sappy melodramatic Christian porn: 12% and And finally, Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed, the plucky new documentary that blows the lid off the anti-creationism conspiracy: 9%.Shoot, Ben Stein can't even beat the Britney Spears epic Crossroads (not the one PZed was interviewed for) which made a stellar 15%. Read the full post at Epsilon Clue.
Expelled in context at Rotten Tomatoes
Epsilon Clue puts the Rotten Tomato ratings of Expelled in the context of some real clunkers. A couple of selected entries:
18 Comments
Quidam · 19 April 2008
That just proves the Darwinian and anti-
God-Intelligent-Designer-who-isn't-a-space-alien conspiracy is wider than than Ben thought.Those reviewers are obviously afraid for their jobs.
James F · 19 April 2008
Zombie Strippers: 40% (all critics), 38% (top critics)
Expelled: 9% (all critics), 0% (top critics)
Big Media: they hate dissent, but they kinda like zombie strippers.raven · 19 April 2008
stevaroni · 19 April 2008
Rick R · 19 April 2008
Anything, absolutely ANYTHING, to avoid admitting they made a crappy movie, even to themselves.
Especially to themselves.
Reed A. Cartwright · 19 April 2008
"Worse than Gigli" comes to mind as I watch the reviews of Expelled come in.
Rocky · 19 April 2008
Speed 2: 4%
Hottie and the Nottie (Paris Hilton): 5%
Frank J · 19 April 2008
Speaking of Britney Spears:
You say Kevin Miller, we say Ken Miller,
You say Caroline Crocker, we say Chris Comer,
Berlinski, Bolinsky, Chris, Crocker, Let's call the whole thing off.
Coming soon to a theater near you: "Expelled II: Leave Ben Stein Alone!"
Stanton · 19 April 2008
There is no way anyone can win with "Expelled," given as how it got a worse rating than "Ishtar"'s 19%.
James F · 19 April 2008
Frank J,
I would love to see a Chris Crocker-style "Leave Ben Stein Alone!" parody.
Ichthyic · 19 April 2008
Their next movie, if they can obtain financing, will be about the downfall of a powerful, advanced nation into a new Dark Ages. It will feature the Inner Party played by Xian Death Cultists and roughly 300 million serfs and slaves played by former Americans. 2084 is coming to a continent near you sooner than you think.
too late, that move has already been made:
Idiocracy
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0387808/
ck1 · 20 April 2008
I have seen "Plan 9" and read the first Left Behind book (not seen the movie).
Plan 9 is clearly among the best, if not the best, bad movies of all times. Not believable in the slightest, but entertaining.
The Left Behind book was pedestrian, melodramatic. Cardboard characters. Unbelievable story line. Not something I would ever read again or recommend to anyone else.
Peter Henderson · 20 April 2008
Peter Henderson · 20 April 2008
Coin · 21 April 2008
I'm not sure it makes sense to compare Expelled's RT score directly to other movies like this, because the number of reviews included in the sample is so relatively small. Most rotten tomatoes scores are based on about 100 reviews. Expelled has 21. "9%" in this case means just that two of the reviewers liked it, one of them from "Christianity Today". I don't know what score Expelled could have received if more places had reviewed it, but I would note that with more reviewers a lone approval from Christianity Today would not be able to bestow 4.5 RT points all by itself.
There's also another odd thing to take into account here: RottenTomatoes scores are often weirdly skewed for documentaries. Documentaries often tend to only be reviewed at all by publications that specifically tend to like documentaries, so they usually have low numbers of reviewers and somewhat inflated scores. Expelled is odd in that respect in that it's a documentary with a very low RT score. Of course, if you look you find that the alt-weekly usual suspects from rottentomatoes aggregations of documentaries aren't so much present and a lot of the people who did write reviews are places like the NYT, who seem to be covering "Expelled" less because they review movies but more as if they are covering its release as a news event.
Ex-drone · 21 April 2008
What if god is inspiring christian filmmakers to produce dreck in order to supply his library of awful movies that evolutionists will be forced to watch in hell for eternity.
Frank J · 21 April 2008
Artfulskeptic · 21 April 2008